TPU vs Silicone: What the Data Sheets Actually Say
One of these two materials can be melted and reused. The other cures once and never melts again. That single split decides more of your quote than any property table.
Almost every comparison page puts a tensile number from one material next to a tensile number from the other. Almost none of them say what grade, what hardness, or what test method produced those numbers.
This page does the opposite. It takes real data sheets from a TPU maker and a silicone maker. The numbers sit side by side, each with its grade attached. Then it shows where the contrast breaks.
After that it answers the question buyers actually ask. Case, strap or cable jacket, which one, and why.
The Short Answer
TPU is a thermoplastic. Heat it and it softens. Cool it and it sets. Do that again and it still works, which is why scrap can be reground.
Silicone is a thermoset. Two parts are mixed, a catalyst starts a chemical reaction, and the result is a new network. Once that network forms, heat will not melt it.
From that one fact, most of the practical behaviour follows.
| Question | TPU | Silicone |
|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength | About 33 to 35 MPa | About 8 to 9 MPa |
| Tear strength | High, and it rises with hardness | Lower, and it depends heavily on grade |
| Feel | Firm, slightly slick, snaps back | Soft, tacky, dry to the touch |
| Heat | Softens, then loses strength | Holds most properties to 200 °C |
| Clear parts | Clear, but only the aliphatic grades stay clear | Clear, with a slight haze |
| Scrap | Regrind and reuse | Cannot be remelted |
That table is a fair summary. It is also useless on its own, because every number in it depends on the grade behind it. The rest of this page is about the grade behind it.
One Melts, One Does Not
TPU stands for thermoplastic polyurethane. It is a block copolymer, which means long soft segments and short hard segments are joined in the same chain.
The hard segments stick to each other and act like physical cross-links. Warm the material and they let go, so the plastic flows. Cool it and they grab again.
Nothing is chemically destroyed in that cycle. That is why a TPU sprue can be ground and moulded again. It is also why two TPU parts can be welded with heat.
Silicone is a different chemistry. Its backbone is a chain of silicon and oxygen atoms, with organic groups hanging off the sides. That backbone is why silicone tolerates heat and why it stays flexible when cold.
The common moulding silicone is a two-part liquid, mixed one to one by weight. A platinum compound starts the cure, and the mix gels in seconds inside a hot tool.
Once cured, the network is fixed. You can cut it, bond it or compress it. You cannot melt it back into a liquid.
For a buyer, it shows up in three places. Scrap value, repair options, and what happens to an overmoulded part.
The Numbers, With the Grade Attached
The data below comes from published sheets. The TPU figures are from BASF Elastollan 1185 A and Elastollan 1180A.
The silicone figures are from three Momentive Silopren liquid silicone grades.
Both families were chosen because they publish full properties with test methods. That is not universal in this industry.
| Property | TPU, Shore A 89 | TPU, Shore A 80 | LSR, Shore A 36 | LSR, Shore A 37 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength | 35 MPa | 4,900 psi, about 34 MPa | 9.0 MPa | 8.0 MPa |
| Elongation at break | 600 % | 590 % | 680 % | 660 % |
| Tear strength | 60 kN/m, DIN ISO 34-1 Bb | 550 lb/in, ASTM D 624 Die C | 18 kN/m, Die B | 33 kN/m, Die B |
| Compression set | 25 % at 23 °C, 45 % at 70 °C | 25 % at 23 °C, 45 % at 70 °C | 20 %, no post-cure | not published |
| Abrasion loss | 35 mm³, DIN ISO 4649-A | 25 mm³, DIN 53516 | not published | not published |
| Specific gravity | 1.23 | 1.11 | 1.12 | 1.11 |
Read the tensile row first. TPU sits around 34 to 35 MPa. Silicone sits at 8 to 9 MPa. That is a factor of about four, and it is real.
Read the elongation row second. Silicone stretches further, 660 to 680 %, against 590 to 600 % for TPU. So silicone pulls apart at a lower force but travels further before it does.
Those two rows together describe the feel gap better than any adjective. A silicone part yields early and keeps going. A TPU part resists and then returns.
Now read the tear row, and notice something odd. The softer TPU grade reports 550 lb/in, which is about 96 kN/m. The harder grade reports 60 kN/m.
The harder grade reports the lower number. That is not a typing error on the data sheet.
Why Those Numbers Mislead
Three things break a simple side-by-side: the test die, the hardness, and the temperature.
Take the die first. Tear strength measures the force needed to keep a cut growing through a strip of material. The shape of that strip and the shape of the nick in it change the answer a lot.
DIN ISO 34-1 Bb and ASTM D 624 Die C are both trouser or angle geometries with different dimensions. Numbers from the two are not interchangeable, even in the same polymer family.
That is why the BASF 1185 A sheet reads 60 kN/m and the BASF 1180A sheet reads about 96 kN/m. A new grade, a new hardness, and a new die all at once.
Take hardness second. In silicone, tear strength climbs steeply with hardness. The Momentive 2735/30 grade at Shore A 25 lists 15 kN/m. The 2640 LV grade at Shore A 37 lists 33 kN/m.
Same material family, same test die, more than double the tear strength, because the grade is 12 points harder.
So a sentence like “silicone tears at 15, TPU at 60” compares a 25 Shore A silicone with an 89 Shore A TPU. Most of that gap is the hardness, not the chemistry.
Take temperature third. A data sheet number is measured at 23 °C unless it says otherwise. Your part will not live at 23 °C.
The TPU sheet is unusually honest here. It prints compression set twice, once at 23 °C for 72 hours and once at 70 °C for 24 hours. The result nearly doubles, from 25 % to 45 %.
The silicone sheet prints one compression set figure, 20 %, and notes that the sample was not post-cured. It does not name a test temperature on that line.
That is not a reason to distrust it. It is a reason to ask for the number at your service temperature before you approve a seal.
There is a fourth trap that has nothing to do with test methods. Water.
The BASF 1185 A sheet gives tensile strength after 42 days in water at 80 °C. It drops from 35 MPa to 20 MPa. That is a 43 % loss, and it is the reason polyether grades exist and why drying matters.
Silicone does not hydrolyse that way. It is one of the few places where the choice is not close.
What Feel Actually Measures
Buyers describe the gap with their hands. Soft, grippy, rubbery, plasticky. Those words are real information, but they do not survive a specification.
The number that gets used instead is Shore A hardness. It comes from a spring-loaded needle pressed into the surface, and the depth it sinks gives the reading. A soft material lets the needle in further, so the number is lower.
Two problems follow. First, Shore A is a single point on a curve. It says how the surface behaves under one small load, and nothing about how the material behaves when stretched to twice its length.
Second, the scales are not the same instrument across materials. A 40 Shore A silicone and a 40 Shore A TPU are not equally soft in the hand, and they are certainly not interchangeable.
TPU data sheets usually publish the missing information. The BASF 1185 A sheet gives stress at 20 %, 100 % and 300 % elongation: 3.5, 8 and 13 MPa. That is a curve, and a curve is what a designer needs.
Silicone sheets in the same family publish tensile, elongation and tear, but not a full stress-strain curve. You get the endpoints, not the path between them.
So when a factory says “same hardness as the sample”, ask which scale, on which material, measured at what thickness. On thin walls, a Shore A reading taken with a hand-held gauge is close to meaningless.
There is a practical shortcut. If the part must grip, silicone wins on surface tack. If the part must slide in and out of a pocket, TPU wins because it is slicker and does not pick up lint.
That tack is also silicone’s weakness. Retail case makers point out that a grippy silicone surface collects dust and fibre. They also note that a thin silicone shell can stretch out of shape over time.
Where Tear Starts in a Real Part
Tear strength is the property buyers should care about most, and the one they ask about least. A part rarely fails by pulling apart in tension. It fails at a nick, a corner or a hole.
Look at a phone case that has split. The split almost always starts at the charging port cut-out or at a corner where two surfaces meet.
That is a stress concentration. A sharp internal corner multiplies the local stress, so a modest load is enough to start a crack. Once started, toughness decides how fast it runs.
This is where TPU’s higher numbers earn their place. At similar thickness, a TPU edge resists a running cut better than a softer silicone edge.
But the answer depends on which TPU grade and which silicone grade. A high-tear silicone at Shore A 37 reaches 33 kN/m. A standard silicone at Shore A 25 reaches 15 kN/m. That is a different material in practice.
So the design rule is not “pick the tougher polymer”. It is: state a minimum tear value with the test method, then design the corner radius so the value is never tested.
For parts that must stretch over a boss or a button, the ranking flips. Silicone’s 660 to 680 % elongation lets it stretch far without splitting, which is why soft buttons and seals are usually silicone.
For read-and-compare purposes, the useful table is the one in the previous section. The unusable table is the one that lists a single tear number per material with no die and no hardness.
Heat, Set and the Seal That Forgets
Compression set is the property that decides whether a seal still seals after a year. It measures how much a squeezed sample fails to spring back.
Low set is good. A gasket with low set keeps pushing back on the surfaces it is clamped between. A gasket with high set takes a new shape and stops pushing.
Here TPU has a real weakness, and its own data sheet states it. Set is 25 % at 23 °C, then 45 % at 70 °C. Warm the part and it forgets its shape almost twice as fast.
Silicone is the material the sealing industry reaches for, and the reason is visible in the same kind of sheet. The low-set LSR grade lists 20 % set, and it is sold specifically as a low-compression-set grade.
There is a second heat number that buyers miss. The Elastollan 1180A sheet gives a Vicat softening temperature of 90 °C.
Ninety degrees is not an exotic condition. A dark part on a car dashboard in summer, or a device left in a parked car, can approach it. TPU does not fail at 90 °C, but it stops being the material on the data sheet.
Silicone is cured at 200 °C in the tool. The Momentive sheets give a mould temperature range of 140 to 230 °C and a cure of about 10 seconds at 200 °C. A material that survives its own cure survives a hot car.
This is the one place where the choice is simple. Anything that must hold a seal under load and at temperature should start as silicone.
Anything that must be tough, thin and abrasion resistant at room temperature should start as TPU. The compression moulding route for silicone rubber covers the tooling side of that first case in more detail.
Yellow: Why a Clear Case Turns Amber
A clear TPU case that has spent a summer on a car dashboard usually turns amber. Buyers often read that as a cheap material. The cause is more specific than that.
Most TPU on the market is aromatic. It is built with MDI, a diisocyanate whose molecule contains a benzene ring.
That ring absorbs ultraviolet light. The absorbed energy breaks bonds, and the broken pieces show up as colour. The part is not dirty. It has changed chemistry.
Aliphatic TPU is built with HDI instead. No benzene ring, no absorption in that band, and clear parts stay clear far longer under the same sun.
Aliphatic grades cost more. That is the whole story behind the price gap between two clear cases that look identical in a product photo.
Silicone does not yellow the same way. Its backbone has no benzene ring, so ultraviolet light does not start the same breakdown. A clear silicone part looks slightly hazy from the start and stays about that hazy.
That is not a free win. Silicone has its own ageing path. It can pick up surface contamination, and its tack holds whatever touches it. The colour holds; the surface does not stay pristine.
The practical rule for a clear part: specify aliphatic TPU in writing, and ask for a UV test report on the actual compound. If the quote came back unusually low, the grade is probably aromatic.
What Each One Does to Your Tool and Your Week
Two materials with similar properties can still produce quotes that look nothing alike. The process around them sets the price.
Start with moisture. TPU absorbs water from the air. The Elastollan sheets are explicit. Dry for 3 to 4 hours at 90 to 110 °C. Keep water content below 0.02 % before the material reaches the barrel.
Skip that step and the water turns to steam inside the melt. The part comes out with silver streaks, and the polymer loses strength through hydrolysis. The damage is not reversible.
That means a dryer on the floor, a drying log, and a rule that hoppers are covered. A factory that quotes TPU without asking about your dryer is quoting a material it may not run well.
Silicone has the opposite problem, and a second one. It arrives as two components that must be mixed one to one. The mix begins curing as soon as the platinum catalyst meets the polymer.
The Momentive sheets warn about this directly. The nozzle and cylinder are kept cool to prevent premature vulcanisation, while the mould runs at 140 to 230 °C.
So the machine holds a cold liquid that must not cure, and injects it into a tool that must cure it in about ten seconds. That balance is the whole skill of liquid silicone moulding.
Shrinkage is the next item. The silicone sheets give 0.027 cm per cm without post-cure, and 0.035 cm per cm after post-cure. That is 2.7 % against 3.5 %.
The same part changes size by nearly a percent just by adding the post-cure step. Tool steel cut to the wrong figure will not be fixed by adjusting the process.
Post-cure is not optional for some parts. It drives off volatiles and it improves compression set. A low-volatile grade is sold with a recommended post-cure of 4 hours at 200 °C in its own data sheet note.
TPU has no post-cure, but it does have a scrap advantage. Sprues and rejects can be ground and blended back at a controlled ratio. Cured silicone cannot be remelted, so silicone scrap is loss.
Put together, the tooling and process picture looks like this.
| Process point | TPU | Liquid silicone |
|---|---|---|
| Before moulding | Dry to below 0.02 % water, 3 to 4 h at 90 to 110 °C | Mix two parts 1:1, keep the feed cool |
| Melt or barrel | 205 to 225 °C | Cool nozzle and cylinder |
| Tool temperature | 15 to 70 °C | 140 to 230 °C |
| Cure or cycle | Cooling time set by wall thickness | About 10 s at 200 °C |
| Shrinkage | Depends on wall thickness, charted by grade | 2.7 %, or 3.5 % after post-cure |
| After moulding | None required | Post-cure for volatiles and set |
| Scrap | Regrind and blend | Loss |
The tooling consequence is easy to state. A TPU tool runs cold and can often use simpler steel. A silicone tool runs hot, needs precise temperature control across the cavity, and needs a cold feed path.
If the moulding route is still open, that choice matters. The piece on prototype tooling against production tooling shows where the money goes before steel is cut.
Case, Strap or Jacket: Which One
Most readers arrive with a part in mind, not a polymer. This section starts from the part.
Clear phone case. Aliphatic TPU. You need transparency, abrasion resistance and a hard edge that does not split. Aromatic TPU will amber within a season.
Grip phone case. Silicone, or a two-layer build with a hard shell and a soft rim. Silicone gives the grip and the dry feel. It will collect lint, and a thin silicone shell can stretch.
Watch strap. Silicone for skin contact and comfort, because it stays soft and holds its shape. TPU gives a firmer strap with better tear resistance at the buckle holes, at the cost of a stiffer feel.
Cable jacket. TPU, almost always. It extrudes, it resists abrasion, and it survives repeated bending. The jacket choice on a USB cable is usually made on flex life and surface finish.
Gasket or seal. Silicone, unless the fluid attacks it. Compression set decides the life of the part, and TPU loses set quickly when warm.
Button, keypad or soft touch pad. Silicone. The elongation lets it travel without splitting, and its set behaviour keeps the return force.
| Part | Pick | Because | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clear case | Aliphatic TPU | Clear, tough, resists pocket abrasion | Aromatic grade ambers in sunlight |
| Grip case | Silicone | Surface tack and dry feel | Collects dust, thin walls stretch |
| Watch strap | Silicone, or firm TPU | Comfort and set, or tear at the holes | Silicone tears at a sharp hole edge |
| Cable jacket | TPU | Extrudable, abrasion resistant, flexes | Must be dried before extrusion |
| Gasket | Silicone | Low compression set when warm | Check the fluid, not just the temperature |
| Button | Silicone | High elongation, stable return force | Over-compression takes the set out |
Two of these choices are close, and two are not. The strap is close, because a firm TPU strap has real advocates. The jacket is not close at all.
If your part is a soft layer over a hard shell, the pair has to be chosen together. Overmoulding a soft layer onto a shell explains why TPU bonds to some plastics and silicone needs help to bond at all.
Seven Lines for the Drawing
An order that says “TPU” or “silicone” names a family, not a material. The factory will pick whatever grade is open that week.
These seven lines close that gap. They also make two quotes comparable.
One. Family and grade name, for example aliphatic polyether TPU, Shore A 85, or platinum-cure LSR, Shore A 40.
Two. Hardness with the scale, and the thickness at which it is measured. A thin wall does not read the same as a thick one.
Three. A minimum tear strength with its test method, written as a number and a standard, not as “high tear”.
Four. Compression set at your service temperature, with hours and temperature stated, if the part is a seal or a spring.
Five. Colour and clarity requirement, including whether aliphatic is required and whether a UV test report is required.
Six. Surface finish, as a texture number or an approved physical sample. This one line settles most arguments later.
Seven. Regrind allowance, if any, and whether post-cure is required for silicone parts.
None of these lines costs anything to write. Each one removes a decision from the factory floor. The wider format is set out in this specification sheet for Chinese factories.
How to Compare Two Quotes
Two quotes for the same part, one in TPU and one in silicone, rarely differ for the reason buyers assume. The material price is only part of it.
Check the grade first. A quote that does not name a grade is not a quote for a material. It is a quote for a family, and the family has grades from 60 Shore A to 74 Shore D.
Check wall thickness second. TPU’s higher tensile strength allows a thinner wall for the same strength. A silicone design often needs more thickness to reach the same tear resistance.
That changes part weight, cycle time and the number of cavities that fit in a tool. All three move the unit price.
Check the process third. A TPU quote assumes a dryer and cold tool. A silicone quote assumes a hot tool, a cold feed, and a post-cure oven. If one quote omits a step, it will appear later as a change order.
Check the test plan fourth. Tear, set and colour are the three properties that decide whether the part survives its first year. If the quote does not include them, the first shipment is the test.
A short checklist to send with the drawing:
Ask for the data sheet of the exact grade, not the family. Ask which test method produced each number. Ask what the compression set is at 70 °C, not just at room temperature. Ask whether the clear grade is aliphatic. Ask what happens to the scrap.
Five questions, one email, and the gap between the two quotes usually explains itself.
Send me the part or the drawing, plus the temperature it will live at. I will tell you which of the two families fits, which grade to name on the order, and the three numbers to demand on the data sheet before a tool is cut. No cost, no obligation.
Send the Part DetailsQuestions Buyers Ask
Is TPU better than silicone for a phone case?
For a clear or slim case, yes, if the grade is aliphatic. For grip and feel, silicone is easier to like. The mistake is ordering TPU without naming the aliphatic grade and then blaming the material for going amber.
Which one is softer, TPU 85A or silicone 85A?
They are not on the same curve, even at the same number. Shore A is a single indentation reading. Ask for stress at 100 % elongation, or better, hold both samples and decide with the part in mind.
Does silicone turn yellow?
Not by the same route as aromatic TPU. Its backbone has no benzene ring for ultraviolet light to attack. A clear silicone part starts slightly hazy and stays roughly that hazy, but its tacky surface will collect dirt.
Can TPU and silicone be bonded to each other?
Not reliably without help. TPU bonds to itself and to some rigid plastics when the substrate melts at the interface. Silicone usually needs a primer or a self-bonding grade, and even then the bond depends on the substrate.
Can silicone scrap be recycled?
Not by remelting. Cured silicone is a thermoset network, so it cannot be returned to a liquid by heat. It can be ground and used as filler in some products, but it does not go back into the same part.
Which one is cheaper?
It depends on the part, not on the material alone. Compare grade, wall thickness, cavity count, scrap rate, post-cure and testing. A silicone quote with a post-cure oven is not comparable to a TPU quote without one.
Questions & Comments
We read every one and reply within 24 hoursA clear case that went amber, or a strap that stopped springing back. Send me the material name from the quote and the temperature the part lives at, and I will say whether the grade can do the job.