Wick Size Chart: Why the Number Is Not Portable
A wick size chart is a lookup table for one wax, one series and one set of conditions. The number in the table does not travel to a different candle.
Every candle supplier publishes one of these charts. They look alike, they use the same numbers, and they disagree.
The reason is simple. A wick is not rated by size alone. It is rated by four things. The wax, the load of fragrance in that wax, the width of the vessel, and how long the candle burns in one go.
This page explains what the chart actually holds, and the four things that move the answer. It also covers the test that replaces guesswork, and the one part of a candle that carries a legal rule.
The Short Answer
A chart gives you a starting size for a stated wax and a stated vessel width. You then make the candle and burn it, and change the size if it fails.
That is the whole method. The chart narrows six options to two. The burn test chooses between the two.
What the chart cannot do is carry across brands. Two suppliers can both list a wick called ECO 6, made from the same cotton by the same mill. The two will still burn differently in your jar if the wax or the load is not identical.
So read a chart as a hypothesis. Treat the first burn as the test that either confirms it or replaces it.
The Chart Has Four Columns, Not One
Most charts print two columns, a wick name and a diameter range. The other two are in the header, in small print, and they are the ones that decide whether the table applies to you.
| Column | What it states | What happens if it is ignored |
|---|---|---|
| Series | Which wick family, for example CD, ECO, LX, HTP or RRD | The number means nothing, because the families are not the same |
| Size | A number inside that family, such as ECO 4 or ECO 12 | Only comparable to other sizes in the same family |
| Wax | Soy, coconut blend, paraffin, or a pillar blend | A soy chart read for paraffin runs two sizes small |
| Vessel | Inside diameter of the jar, not the volume in ounces | A 200 gram jar and a 400 gram jar can share a diameter |
The four families are not interchangeable, and that is the part buyers miss. A CD 10 and an ECO 10 are both ten in their own scale and neither is ten of anything shared.
The families differ in how the tip behaves as it burns. Some are built to curl into the flame and self trim. Some hold rigid. Some are made for vegetable wax and some for paraffin, because the two waxes melt and draw differently.
A supplier will tell you which family it stocks. Ask which family the chart is written for before you read a single row of it.
Four Things Move the Size
Between the chart and your candle sit four variables. Each one pushes the wick in a known direction, and three of them are chosen by you, not by the wax.
| Variable | What it does | What to do about it |
|---|---|---|
| Wax | Sets the base rate, because each wax melts and draws at its own speed | Start from the chart written for that wax |
| Fragrance load | Oil thins the melt and slows the draw, so more oil needs a larger wick | Test at the load you will sell, not at a lower one |
| Dye and additives | Colour and some additives thicken the melt | A dark, heavily dyed batch can need one size up |
| Vessel diameter | Sets the width the melt pool has to cross | Use the inside diameter, measured at the widest point |
Fragrance load is the one that catches most brands. A candle tested at 6 percent and sold at 10 percent is a different candle, and the wick chosen for the first will struggle in the second.
It fails in a specific way. The wick burns down faster than the pool spreads, so wax is left on the wall. After three burns the candle has a ring of hard wax and a hole in the middle, and the customer photographs it.
Dye works the same way in reverse. A pale candle and a black candle from one batch can need two wicks. That is why a colour range is a testing job, not only an artwork job.
The Cure Step Nobody Puts in the Chart
Fragrance needs time to bind with wax after pouring. In a jar candle that rest is usually a few days, and it changes how the candle burns.
Test a candle the day after pouring and the oil is still mobile. The flame runs hot, the pool spreads wide, and the wick looks correct. Test the same candle after a week and the pool is smaller.
So a wick can pass a test that was run too early. That is the single most common reason a brand with a good sample ends up with a bulk complaint.
Write the rest days into the brief, and make the sample that gets approved a sample that has rested for the full period. If the supplier cannot hold stock for a week, the test has to wait.
The Burn Test: Three Cycles and Four Failures
The test is not complicated. It is three burns of three hours each, with a rest and a trim between them, and a record of what happened.
Three hours is the usual cycle because a customer rarely burns longer in one go. A candle that only works on a five hour burn is a candle that will tunnel in real use.
| Check | Pass | Fail |
|---|---|---|
| Melt pool | Reaches the wall by the end of the second burn | A ring of solid wax left at the top third |
| Flame height | Steady, about one inch above the wax | Tall and flickering, or drowning in the pool |
| Soot | Glass stays clear above the wax line | A grey film or black marks on the jar |
| Wick in the pool | Tip stays visible and curls as designed | Tip curls into the wax and goes out |
Four failures cover almost everything. Tunnelling means the wick is too small. Sooting means it is too large, or the fragrance is not fully bound. A wick that drowns means too small for the oil load. A mushrooming tip means the wick is drawing more oil than it can burn.
Shoot one photo per burn, from the side and from above. The photos are the record, and they settle any later argument about what the sample did.
The Wick Is the Regulated Part
Most of a candle is unregulated. The wick is the exception, and the rule is about what is inside a metal core.
What the CPSC requires of a wick is short. Metal-cored wicks, and any candle that uses one, must not contain lead in the core above 0.06 percent by weight, under 16 CFR 1500.17(a)(13). That has applied to products made or imported on or after 15 October 2003.
Two practical points follow. A bulk shipment of metal-cored wicks has to state on the shipping package that it conforms to that citation. And a candle that is subject to the rule needs a General Certificate, with the citation written in it.
A cotton or paper wick, with no metal core, carries none of that. That is one reason a supplier may steer you towards a non-metal wick when you ask about paperwork.
The fire safety side is voluntary. The CPSC lists ASTM F2417 for candle fire safety and ASTM F2058 for the warning label wording. A large retailer will ask you to meet both, even though no federal rule names them.
There is a third standard in the same list that matters when you buy glass: ASTM F2179 covers annealed glass containers made for candles. A jar that cracks at the base after two burns is a glass problem, not a wick problem, and it has its own specification.
The label also has a federal floor. How the net weight statement is set sits in 16 CFR part 500. Wax weight, not jar volume, is the number that goes on the front panel.
What to Put in the Spec
Eight lines carry a candle brief, and the wick is only one of them. The other seven are the conditions that make the wick work.
| Field | Example entry | What it protects |
|---|---|---|
| Wick series and size | ECO 6, cotton, no metal core | Repeatability across batches |
| Wax and supplier | Coconut soy blend, named producer | Two blends of one name behave differently |
| Fragrance load | 8 percent, tolerance plus or minus 0.5 | The variable that most often breaks a wick |
| Vessel inside diameter | 68 mm, measured at the widest point | The number the chart is actually about |
| Pour temperature | Stated in degrees, with a range | Affects how the wax sets and draws |
| Cure days | 7 days before packing or testing | Stops a good sample becoming a bad bulk |
| Burn test | Three cycles of three hours, four checks | Turns the chart into a decision |
| Label set | Warning wording, net wax weight | The retail requirement, before print |
Two of those lines are usually missing from a first brief, and both concern time: the cure days and the burn cycle. A factory will ship without them, because nothing on its line stops.
Why Wick Cost Never Decides
A wick costs a few cents. A failed batch of candles costs the wax, the glass, the fragrance, the labels, the labour and the freight, and then it costs the customer.
The ratio is large enough that the choice is not close. Buy the wick that passes the test, at whatever it costs inside its family, and put the effort into the test instead.
Where cost does matter is the family and the format. A non-metal wick avoids the certificate paperwork on the wick itself. A wood wick changes the burn curve and has its own sizing logic. Treat a wood wick as a new test, not a swap.
Which brings the decision back to the brief. State the series, the load and the vessel, run three burns, and keep the photos.
Two More Charts, the Same Trap
A wick chart is not the only table in a candle order that gets read as if the numbers were transferable.
The inspection table is the second. An AQL figure is tied to a lot size and a level, and copying a number from another brand’s report gives you a different promise. Another chart that is read the wrong way covers how the three numbers relate.
The third is the minimum. A glass supplier, a wax supplier and a wick supplier each set their own, and the highest one becomes your order size. Which supplier sets the floor explains which one binds.
Weight matters here more than in most products. A candle is glass plus wax, so a pallet is heavy and the bill follows the kilograms, not the cartons. That is why what glass weight does to the freight bill decides the route before the wax does.
All four documents, the wick chart, the inspection table, the minimum and the freight rate, end up in one place. If you already keep one document for all four numbers, add the candle fields to it and keep one file.
The commercial side of the category, from wax sourcing to filling, sits in the candle line as a product to sell.
Questions Buyers Ask About Wick Size Charts
How do I read a wick size chart?
Start with the series and the wax the chart was written for. Then find your vessel’s inside diameter. Then move one size up if your fragrance load is above the load the chart assumes.
Is a bigger wick always better?
No. Too large and the flame soots the glass and burns the oil too fast. Too small and the candle tunnels. The right size is the one that clears the wall in three hours without smoke.
Why does my wick work in a sample and fail in bulk?
Usually the sample was burned before the fragrance had cured. A candle tested the day after pouring runs hot and looks fine. Test again after a week and the pool is smaller.
Do I need a certificate for a candle wick?
Only for metal-cored wicks. Those must meet the lead limit in 16 CFR 1500.17(a)(13) and the shipment carries a conformity statement. A cotton or paper wick has no such requirement.
Can I use the same wick for two jar sizes?
Only if the inside diameters match. A tall narrow jar and a short wide jar can hold the same weight of wax and need very different wicks, because the pool has further to travel sideways.
How long should a candle burn in a test?
Three hours at a time, three times, with a trim and a rest between. That matches how a customer uses it, and it exposes tunnelling that a single long burn would hide.
The Bottom Line
A wick chart is a hypothesis about one wax in one vessel. It is useful, it is not transferable, and the only thing that settles it is three burns with photographs.
Write the series, the load, the diameter and the cure days into the brief. Then test at the load you will sell. The wick itself costs cents, and the batch is what costs money.
Send the Jar, Get the Wick
Send the jar’s inside diameter, the wax and the fragrance load you plan to sell. We will name the series and the starting size, then ask the plant for the cure days and the burn test record before you approve the sample.
Send the Brief
Questions & Comments
We read every one and reply within 24 hoursTwo cotton pique quotes that sit a third apart? Tell us the weight and the yarn count on each and we will say which line is carrying the gap.