What Is IPC-A-610: A Rulebook for Judging a Solder Joint
A solder joint passes or fails on a measured number.
IPC-A-610 is the document that supplies those numbers. Its full title is Acceptability of Electronic Assemblies. It tells an inspector what to accept, what to flag, and what to reject on a finished board.
The current edition is IPC-A-610J, published in March 2024 by IPC, the trade association that writes it. The first edition appeared in 1983 as a 24-page guide. The book now runs to hundreds of pages of photographs and measured limits.
That length is the point. A buyer in Europe and a line inspector in Shenzhen can point at the same paragraph. That ends the argument without either side losing face.
The Short Answer
IPC-A-610 is a visual acceptance standard. It answers one question. Given this finished assembly, is it good enough for its class?
It is not a process standard. It does not tell a factory which oven profile to run or how much flux to apply. Those sit in IPC J-STD-001, a separate book with its own class system.
It is also not a certificate. Holding a copy proves nothing. What matters is which class was ordered, and whether the people judging the boards were trained to that class.
Three things follow for a buyer. You choose the class. You write it into the order. You accept that the class changes the price.
Three Classes, and One Person Chooses
Section 1.3 of the standard divides all work into three classes. The names are the standard’s own, and they are worth learning because quotes use them as shorthand.
| Class | What it means in plain words | Typical product |
|---|---|---|
| Class 1 General Electronic Products | The main requirement is that the unit works. Appearance and long life are secondary. | Toys, disposable devices, budget accessories |
| Class 2 Dedicated Service Electronic Products | Continued performance and a long life are required. A short interruption is tolerated. | Most consumer and commercial electronics |
| Class 3 High Reliability Electronic Products | Performance on demand is critical. Downtime cannot be accepted, and the environment may be harsh. | Medical, aerospace, defence, some automotive |
The class is not a grade of factory. The same line can build all three. What changes is how much of the output is rejected, how many checks are recorded, and how much time each board takes.
The customer assigns the class. An inspector does not pick it, and a factory cannot award it to itself. If the order is silent, the class is undefined, and the factory will fall back on whatever it runs every day.
For most contract manufacturers that daily default is Class 2. It balances cost against reliability, and it fits the bulk of commercial work.
A class is not a fixed property of a product either. The same model can be ordered at Class 2 for one market and Class 3 for another. The drawing is the only thing that records the difference, and the price follows the drawing.
Two mistakes cost money, and they point in opposite directions. Writing Class 3 on a product that sits in a warehouse buys checks nobody needs. Writing nothing on a product that must not fail hands the decision to the cheapest party in the room.
What an Inspector Actually Measures
This is where the standard stops being abstract. For each joint type it lists named dimensions with letters, and each letter has a limit that changes with class.
On through-hole parts, section 7 covers three things. Vertical fill of the barrel (A), the gap between lead and barrel wall (B), and how much of the land is covered (C, D, E).
On surface-mount parts, section 8 goes further. It names eight things. Side overhang (A), end overhang (B), end joint width (C), side joint length (D). Then maximum fillet height (E), minimum fillet height (F), solder thickness (G) and end overlap (J).
Read that list again as a buyer. Each letter marks a place where a joint can go wrong. Too small, too large, or offset. The inspector is not forming an opinion about shine or beauty. They are comparing a measured shape to a table.
This also explains a common disagreement. A buyer looks at a photo of a joint and says it looks fine. An inspector looks at the same joint and rejects it, because the fillet is tall enough but the end joint width is short.
The standard also has a section on soldering anomalies in chapter 5. Cold connections, dewetting, nonwetting, excess solder, bridging, disturbed solder, fractured solder, fillet lift and hot tears all appear there by name. That list is useful in a claim: cite the fault name rather than describing it.
Four Words the Standard Uses Precisely
Section 1.5.1 defines the words an inspector is allowed to use. They are not synonyms, and using one in place of another causes most disputes.
| Word | What it means | What it lets you do |
|---|---|---|
| Acceptable | The condition meets the rules for this class. | Ship it |
| Defect | The condition fails the rules for this class. | Reject, rework or scrap |
| Process indicator | Not a defect. It shows the process is drifting. | Watch it. Do not reject on it alone |
| Not specified | The standard is silent on this condition. | Agree it in writing. Silence is not a defect |
The third row is the one buyers get wrong. A process indicator is a warning about the line, not a fault in the part. Rejecting a shipment on a process indicator alone gives the supplier a fair reason to push back.
The fourth row matters just as much. When a condition is not covered, the standard does not default to rejection. It defaults to nothing, which means the two sides have to agree. Put that agreement in the order before the first lot ships.
One more word deserves care. When the standard says a thing should be done, it is a recommendation. When it says shall, it is a requirement. Claims that quote a recommendation as a rule are easy to answer.
Your Order Outranks the Standard
Section 1.7 deals with a case every buyer meets: two papers say different things. The standard sets an order, and it is not the order most people assume.
First comes the procurement agreement between buyer and maker. Second comes the drawing that carries your requirements. Third comes IPC-A-610 itself, and only if your documents cite it.
That last clause is the whole mechanism. The standard does not apply to your order unless your paperwork calls it up. A factory that owns the book and never cites it is not working to it.
Section 1.9 adds a second duty. Rules must flow down. If you buy a finished unit from a box builder, the class you asked for has to reach the board house that solders the panel. Ask how the requirement is passed on, and ask to see it in their own order to the sub-supplier.
Published summaries of the standard spell the same order out, which makes it easy to check before a meeting. The section number also appears in the table of contents of the current edition, which IPC publishes as a free PDF.
It Is Not J-STD-001
The two books are often named in the same sentence, and they do different jobs.
J-STD-001 is a requirements standard for making the joint. It covers solder alloy, flux, process control, equipment and the room itself. Its title is Requirements for Soldered Electrical and Electronic Assemblies.
IPC-A-610 is a judging standard for looking at the result. It carries the photographs, the dimensions with letters, and the limits per class.
Both use the same three classes, which is convenient and also a trap. Citing one does not pull in the other. A quote that says “built to IPC” without a document number and a class tells you nothing.
The practical pairing is to cite both, at the same revision level, and to name which one wins if they disagree. If only the inspection standard is cited, the factory is free to choose any process that produces parts the inspector will pass.
Who Is Allowed to Judge
Section 1.10 covers people, not parts. Instructors, operators and inspectors must show they are fit for the work they do.
The evidence named there is ordinary. Education, experience, training and testing. Where it is missing, the standard asks for supervision and on-the-job training until the person is ready.
IPC also runs a training programme with several levels. The operator and inspector level is the one that matters on a line. That credential carries an expiry date, so it is renewed.
“Our staff is IPC trained” is therefore a claim, not a document. The useful question is narrower. How many people, at which level, in which standard, and when does each one expire?
Keep the answer. If a lot is rejected later and the inspector turns out to have been untrained, the argument ends quickly. Keep the training records in the lot file. When a claim arrives a year later, that file is the only thing that still remembers who checked the boards.
Why a Photograph Proves Nothing
Section 1.13 covers how the check is done, and it is short enough that people skip it. It names the light on the bench, how far the view is zoomed, and the angle.
Those three settings change what a joint looks like. A fillet that looks full under a desk lamp can look hollow under a ring light at ten times zoom. Neither view is wrong. They are two instruments.
The photos in the standard show a condition. They are not a picture to match against. A buyer who sends a photo from another project and says “ours does not look like this” has started a conversation that cannot be won.
Two habits settle it. Agree the zoom and the light in the order, so the inspector and the auditor see the same thing. Then sign a golden sample from the first approved lot, keep one copy at each end, and measure against that. Photograph it under the same light the line uses. Two photos taken under two lamps will restart the argument six months later.
Six Lines for the Order
Everything above collapses into a short block of text. The format is the same one used for any specification sheet sent to a Chinese factory, so it costs nothing to add.
One. Name the standard and the edition: IPC-A-610J, not “IPC”. Editions differ, and the letter at the end is the version.
Two. Name the class, as a number and as words: Class 2, Dedicated Service Electronic Products.
Three. Name the process standard too, usually J-STD-001 at the same class, and say which document wins if the two disagree.
Four. Set the check basis: every board or a sample, at what zoom and under what light.
Five. Say what is recorded and for how long. Class 3 without records is a word on a drawing.
Six. Require the class to flow down to any sub-supplier who solders or coats the board, and ask for the clause that does it. The person who signs the golden sample should be the person who will check the next lot, not the sales office.
The same logic applies to cable assemblies, which sit under a different document. If the product includes a harness, the soldering standard does not cover the crimps and the cable build needs its own acceptance rules.
None of this replaces a test report or a safety mark. A board can be built to Class 3 and still fail a product safety check. Workmanship and safety are separate questions, as this guide to what a UL mark actually covers sets out. The mark side of the same order is covered in the CE and RoHS guide for electronics.
Send me the drawing or the RFQ reply you were given. I will tell you whether a class is named at all, whether the edition is current, and which two lines to add before tooling starts. No cost, no obligation.
Check My ClassQuestions Buyers Ask
Is IPC-A-610 a law?
No. It is a voluntary industry standard. It binds a supplier only when your order or drawing cites it, which is why the section on precedence puts your paperwork first.
What changes between Class 2 and Class 3?
The measured limits tighten. A fillet that passes in Class 2 can fail in Class 3 on height or width. More boards are checked, more records are kept, and yields fall. One contract manufacturer puts the added cost at up to 50 %, which is their figure rather than an industry average.
Can a factory be IPC certified?
Partly. Certificates are issued to people, not to buildings, so what you can check is the inspectors. A factory can hold a training licence, but that is a different claim from having trained people on your line today.
Does it cover cables and wire harnesses?
No. Cable and harness work sits under IPC/WHMA-A-620, which uses its own matching class numbers. A box build often needs both documents cited on the same order.
Can I reject a lot because a joint looks wrong in a photo?
Not reliably. The standard asks for measured dimensions at a stated magnification, not resemblance to a picture. A signed golden sample plus the agreed magnification is a far stronger position.
What is a process indicator?
A condition that is neither acceptable nor a defect. It signals that a process is drifting, so it should trigger a look at the line rather than a rejection of the part.
Questions & Comments
We read every one and reply within 24 hoursIf a supplier answered IPC and nothing else, send me the exact wording. Send me the file number from the label and I will tell you whether it survives a lookup, and whether the factory on the paper matches yours.