How to Choose a Sleeping Bag: Read the Rating, Then the Three Things It Hides
Buy to the comfort rating, not the extreme one. The extreme figure is a survival number that allows frostbite, so it belongs nowhere near a buying decision.
Three numbers sit on a sleeping bag label: comfort, limit and extreme. Comfort is the temperature a standard woman sleeps through for 8 hours. Limit is the same test for a standard man. Extreme is the point where survival is possible.
Choose on comfort and allow a margin for how you sleep. A cold sleeper who buys to the limit figure will have a bad night at the stated temperature.
That is the short answer. The longer answer is that the rating comes with conditions, and the conditions are not printed on the label.
What the Three Numbers Actually Measure
The test runs in a certified laboratory, in a cold chamber. A heated mannequin wearing standard base layers goes into the bag, and the bag goes onto an insulated pad.
Sensors measure how much energy per unit area it takes to hold the mannequin at a standard skin temperature. The result is compared against reference bags. The three ratings are calculated from that.
That is the EN 13537 protocol as Sea to Summit describes it. The protocol has since been published as ISO 23537, and the 2022 edition covers bags with limit temperatures of −20 °C and higher.
Read that last part as a boundary. The standard does not test below −20 °C, so a winter bag sold for a colder trip is outside the range the numbers cover.
The three ratings map like this. Comfort is the temperature at which a standard woman sleeps for 8 hours. Limit is the same for a standard man. Extreme is a survival rating that does not rule out frostbite.
Sea to Summit is blunt about the third one: it advises buyers to disregard the extreme rating. A pack that leads with the extreme number is selling the least useful figure on the label.
| Rating | Who it is measured on | What it means for a night out |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | A standard woman, eight hours | The number to buy against |
| Limit | A standard man, 8 hours | Useful for a warm sleeper, risky for anyone else |
| Extreme | Survival, not sleep | Ignore it in a buying decision |
Notice what the test does not set: any figure for how the sleeper is dressed, beyond the standard base layers. Two people in the same bag at the same temperature can have different nights. The bag is one part of what they wear and lie on.
The Rating Assumes a Pad You May Not Own
This is the sentence that changes how the whole label should be read. The lab test runs the bag on a sleeping pad with an R-value of at least 4.
R-value measures resistance to heat loss. A higher number means a warmer pad. Sea to Summit states plainly that if a buyer uses a pad with a lower R-value, the bag may not reach its stated rating.
Most three-season pads sold alongside these bags sit below that figure. So the number on the hangtag describes a system that includes a pad the customer has not bought yet.
For a buyer ordering bags, that is a specification line and a marketing risk in one. Print the assumption, or accept returns from customers who tested the bag on a thin foam mat in April.
The pad is also where the cheap build shows. A bag loses heat downward faster than it loses it upward, because the ground is colder than the air on most nights. Insulation under the body is compressed by body weight and stops working.
That is why a foam pad with an R-value around 2.1 is described as enough for warm weather, and why a winter trip needs more. The bag cannot compensate for what happens underneath it.
One Bag Tested, a Whole Series Sold
The protocol allows a supplier to test a single bag and extend the results across the rest of the series. That is legal, and it is common.
Sea to Summit says it tests each bag on its own and does not round results down to round numbers. Most brands do not make that statement, which tells you the practice exists.
For a buyer, this is a question with a yes or no answer. Ask whether each size and each colourway in the series was tested, or whether one sample carried the numbers for the range.
The difference matters most at the ends of a range. A short bag and a long bag have different internal volume, and a small bag and a large one lose heat at different rates. Extending one result across sizes is the weakest version of an already approximate test.
Put the answer in writing. A supplier who says each size was tested will not mind the question. A supplier who says the range shares one test is telling you the truth, and you can price that honestly.
What the Mannequin Cannot Feel
The mannequin does not move. It lies still for the whole test, and that single fact removes three of the parts that decide a real night.
A moving sleeper presses knees and hips into the insulation and creates cold spots. A moving sleeper draws cold air in at the shoulders. A moving sleeper pushes the draft tube away from the zip.
None of that happens to a mannequin, so a hood, a draft collar and a well-built draft tube do not show up in the rating. Sea to Summit makes this point directly, and it is the reason two bags with the same number can feel different.
Those three parts are also the cheapest place to save money in production. A hood is fabric and fill and labour. A draft tube is a tube of fill sewn along the zip. A draft collar is a second tube at the neck.
| Part | In the rating? | What it does on a real night |
|---|---|---|
| Hood | No | Holds warmth around the head |
| Draft collar | No | Blocks cold air at the neck |
| Draft tube | No | Stops air moving through the zip |
| Shell fabric | Partly | Blocks wind, must still let moisture out |
| Fill | Yes | Does the insulating |
This is why the rating is a floor and not a promise. Two bags at the same comfort figure can differ by a season once the hood and the draft tube are built properly.
It also tells an inspector where to look. A rating test will not catch a draft tube that was left out to save cost. A physical check will.
Fill: a Cost Line Before It Is a Comfort Line
Down and synthetic are usually presented as a warmth debate. In an order they are a cost and a packing decision, and the warmth follows.
Down packs smaller for the same warmth and lasts longer if it is looked after. It also costs more per bag and it loses its loft when it is stored compressed for months.
Synthetic fill is cheaper, handles damp better and keeps more of its loft when wet. It is bulkier for the same warmth and it degrades faster across seasons of use.
For a buyer the split usually follows the channel. A bag sold to backpackers competes on pack size, so down earns its cost. A bag sold for car camping competes on price and on how it handles a damp tent, so synthetic is easier to defend.
What matters for the order is the weight of fill, not the name of it. Two bags with the same shell and the same fill weight will rate close together, whatever the fill is called.
Shape and Length Decide Who Fits
Three shapes cover the market. A mummy bag is narrow at the feet and has a hood, so it holds heat with less fill. A rectangular bag is roomier and colder for the same fill. A quilt removes the back panel and relies on the pad.
Quilts have become common among backpackers for a simple reason: fill under the body is compressed and does nothing. Removing it saves weight and money. The trade is that a quilt depends on the pad far more than a bag does, which brings the R-value question back to the front.
A quilt also needs attachment points. Straps or a clip system hold it to the pad, and a quilt without them slides off during the night. For an order, list the strap count and the pad width the quilt is cut for. A quilt made for a wide pad is loose on a narrow one.
Length is the other half. A bag that is too long has more air to heat and more fill doing nothing. A bag that is too short compresses the foot and creates a cold spot at the toes.
For an order, list the internal length and the shoulder and hip widths, and state the tolerance. Those four numbers decide whether the bag fits the customer, and they are the numbers a sample check can measure with a tape.
No One Has to Test Before Printing a Number
In North America there is no legal requirement that a sleeping bag be tested before a rating is claimed. Sea to Summit says so plainly on its own page.
That does not make the numbers meaningless, because the brands that lead the market mostly test anyway. It does mean the number is a claim, not a certificate, and a claim can be copied from another product.
This is the risk a buyer carries and a customer does not see. A bag that carries a comfort figure with no test behind it will sell. It will also return in volume once the first cold night happens.
The remedy is a paper trail, not a conversation. Ask which standard the figure was produced under, which lab, and whether each size was tested or the range was extrapolated.
Four Lines for the Order Sheet
A sleeping bag order that can be inspected has 4 things written down. Each one corresponds to something the label does not tell you.
The rating and its basis. State comfort and limit, the standard they were produced under, and whether each size was tested. This is the line that stops a supplier quoting the extreme figure.
Fill weight and shell. Grams of fill, the shell fabric and its denier. Fill weight is the comparable number across suppliers, and it is the one a lab can check by weighing.
The three parts the test ignores. Hood, draft collar and draft tube, described as present with a fill weight each. Without a number next to them, they are the first thing to disappear in a second production run.
Dimensions and tolerance. Internal length, shoulder width, hip width and foot width, with a tolerance. These are measured with a tape, so they cost nothing to check and they catch a size drift early.
Writing those four things into the sheet turns a comfort claim into something a third party can check. Then a check on the finished bags has a measurement for every line, including the draft tube that no lab test will ever look at.
On a long run, a visit while the batch is still on the line catches the substitution sooner than a final check does. Fill weight is easy to reduce mid-run and hard to see in a packed bag.
If a batch does come in light, the cost question has its own rules. What a failed inspection is worth is settled by the sheet, not by the argument after it.
Questions Buyers Ask About Choosing a Sleeping Bag
Should I choose by comfort or limit rating?
Choose by comfort, then add margin. Limit is measured on a standard man for 8 hours, so anyone who sleeps cold will find it optimistic.
Is the extreme rating useful at all?
It is a survival figure that allows frostbite. It tells you the bag will not kill someone at that temperature, and nothing about sleeping.
Why does my bag feel cold at its stated temperature?
Two likely reasons. The pad underneath is below the R-value 4 the test assumes, or the hood and draft tube are weaker than the test can measure.
Does a higher price buy a warmer bag?
Not directly. Price tracks fill type, fill weight and the parts the test ignores. Two bags at the same comfort rating can differ by a season.
Down or synthetic for a first bag?
Synthetic for car camping, because it tolerates damp and costs less. Down for backpacking, because it packs smaller for the same warmth.
Is a sleeping bag rating certified?
Not in North America, where there is no legal duty to test before claiming a number. It becomes certified when a buyer asks for the standard and the lab.
The Short Version
Buy to the comfort figure, allow for how you sleep, and ignore the extreme number. Then check the three conditions behind the label. The pad it assumes, whether every size was tested, and whether the hood and draft tube were built.
A bag is half of a sleep system. The other half is what it lies on.
Ask Which Number the Supplier Is Quoting
Ordering sleeping bags and the quotes look similar? Send the comfort figure, the fill weight and the pad you expect customers to use. We will say whether the rating is tested or extrapolated, and which build lines the sheet is missing before you approve a sample.
Send the Brief
Questions & Comments
We read every one and reply within 24 hoursQuoting sleeping bags and not sure which rating the supplier is using? Tell us the comfort figure, the fill weight and the pad your customers use, and we will name the line the sheet is missing.